Weather Forecast


Unruly, uncommunicative, unacceptable

Senate Taxes Chairman Tom Bakk, DFL-Cook, left, listens to a debate in this undated photo. Bakk wants to extend the sales tax to clothing items to raise funding for the state's problematic budget. Tribune photo by Scott Wente

ST. PAUL - The 2009 Minnesota Legislature will be remembered as the un-session.

Unruly: As midnight arrived Monday, Republican senators were shouting to be recognized and called the end of the session a shame and a disgrace.

Uncommunicative: In the last few days of the five-month session, when leaders and the governor were supposed to work out a budget deal, they seldom even talked about meeting.

Unchanged: Talk at the beginning of the year was that a massive budget deficit gave lawmakers a chance to reform how they do things.

Unsportsmanlike: For the first time in years, there was no serious talk about funding a new sports stadium.

Unacceptable: The governor refused to accept state tax increases; Democrats who control the Legislature refused to do without more taxes.

And the biggest un, unallot: Now, Gov. Tim Pawlenty begins looking at what he can cut from budget bills lawmakers passed, a process known as unallotment.

After nearly five months in St. Paul, lawmakers ended their session at 12:01 a.m. Tuesday, a minute after the constitutional deadline, amid shouting on the House and Senate floors. The Senate, in particular, was raucous as seven Republican senators rose to talk about a $1 billion tax increase plan they just were given as time ran out. Democratic leaders refused to let them debate the measure.

"Never have I seen anything like this," said the usually quiet Senate Minority Leader Dave Senjem, R-Rochester. "This is not the way Minnesota governs."

Minnesotans are going to see something else they never have seen - a governor cutting $2.7 billion out of the state budget.

"The legislators are gone and they are not coming back," a determined Pawlenty said Tuesday, outlining plans to begin planning the cuts this week.

The GOP governor said he will convene a meeting of key Cabinet members and staff on Thursday to start unallotment planning.

The governor said the state's 2010-11 budget funded by state taxes and fees will be $33.1 billion, a drop of nearly 4 percent from the current two-year budget. It will be the first time in state history that one budget is smaller than its predecessor.

But the economy leaves the state no choice, Pawlenty said.

"The sky is not going to fall," he added. "We can get through this."

Democrats and people dependent upon state money are worried. They blame Pawlenty for the state's economic problems, because he repeatedly beat back their attempts to raise taxes to help fund schools, local governments and health care programs.

"While the governor and the legislative leaders are content to blame each other, Minnesota communities are about to be delivered a body blow in the form of huge property taxes and cuts to public safety, libraries and other critical services," Wadena Mayor Wayne Wolden said. "Minnesota is now headed toward the unallotment cliff."

Sen. LeRoy Stumpf, DFL-Plummer, said conflict that arose during the session was framed around two basic philosophical beliefs: Smaller government is better vs. tax increases are justified to fund basic services.

State government's budget troubles are not over, Stumpf predicted, claiming that Pawlenty's budget strategy will create more financial problems in the coming years.

"In the end, the battle's not done," he said.

Lawmakers left the Capitol frustrated with the legislative process.

"All of us -- Democrats and Republicans -- have to find a better way to get our job done," said Rep. Pat Garofalo, R-Farmington. "As far as I'm concerned, these last four and a half months we spent a lot of time yelling at each other back and forth, but no one listened. It's just disappointing."

House Minority Leader Marty Seifert, R-Marshall, said lawmakers had a chance this year to make major budget reforms, but Democrats who control the Legislature "squandered four or five months of time."

"It's a messy session but it was a messy budget," Seifert said as lawmakers left the Capitol.

Senate Tax Chairman Tom Bakk, DFL-Cook, said that Democratic leaders ordered him to draw up the tax increase five hours before the constitutional adjournment deadline. It would provide proof that Democrats tried to balance the budget.

"There had not been an actual balanced budget put on the governor's desk," Bakk said.

The bill would have raised taxes $1 billion and delayed $1.7 billion in school payments, but Pawlenty expects to veto it as soon as it arrives in his office.