Summit Carbon Solutions updates Kandiyohi County Board on pipeline progress in Minnesota, Iowa, Dakotas

Summit Carbon Solutions, which hopes to build a 2,000-mile-long carbon dioxide pipeline across Minnesota, Iowa and the Dakotas, spoke about the current status of the proposed project at the May 16 Kandiyohi County Board meeting.

Joe Caruso of Summit Carbon Solutions presents in front of the Kandiyohi County Board
Joe Caruso, with Summit Carbon Solutions, updates the Kandiyohi County Board at its May 16 meeting on the carbon dioxide pipeline that could go through Kandiyohi County.
Contributed screenshot / Kandiyohi County

WILLMAR — While the proposed Summit Carbon Solutions carbon dioxide pipeline through areas of the state might be Minnesota's first such pipeline, it most likely won't be the only — or the last.

"We are the first one here. We are not going to be the last in Minnesota," said Joe Caruso, Minnesota external affairs coordinator for Summit, at the May 16 meeting of the Kandiyohi County Board .

Part of the more than 2,000-mile pipeline will go right through Kandiyohi County — from Bushmills Ethanol in Atwater diagonally across to the borders with Chippewa and Renville counties, where the pipeline will meet up with Granite Falls Energy before heading south.

More Kandiyohi County Board:
A Kandiyohi County property that housed an antiques business will now be a second home to Hinterland Vineyards. The construction business that was going to locate there will now occupy land the vineyard was initially going to develop.
It is hoped the rate increase approved by the Kandiyohi County Board will allow Greater Minnesota Family Services to hire and retain staff, which will allow it to continue to provide services to children struggling with behavioral and mental health issues.
The Kandiyohi County Board tabled a resolution to have the county take over all property assessments. The action will give townships and cities to give commissioners feedback.
With land acquired, Tepetonka Club can begin the permitting process for a proposed destination golf course in rural New London, Minnesota.
Presently, more than 4,400 parcels are assessed by a local assessor, not the county. That could change moving forward.
A resolution for Kandiyohi County to take over all property assessments in the county is on the board agenda for Tuesday, May 16.
Dr. Cindy Firkins Smith, of CentraCare, spoke recently to the Kandiyohi County Board about the future of rural health care.
Willmar-based garbage and recycling services company West Central Sanitation had the highest bid for the purchase of Kandiyohi County's former recycling facility in southwest Willmar.
The presentations and updates include children's mental health, foster care, adult mental health and protection, the Sheriff's Department, rural health care and Woodland Centers.
The Kandiyohi County Board has approved the creation of a local housing trust fund. Monies in the fund will be used to help make housing projects a reality.

With the state taking over all permitting for the pipeline, Kandiyohi County doesn't have much say in the project, but Summit Carbon has said it will be as transparent as possible with the impacted counties, hence the at least annual stops at county boards. The company also had plans to meet with the Chippewa, Renville and Yellow Medicine County boards this month.

"We are trying to be as transparent and courteous as we can be and be communicating with county boards on a regular basis, whether in person or in writing," Caruso said.


The project is planned to capture, transport and permanently store up to 18 million tons of carbon dioxide from 34 biofuel plants along the pipeline branches in Iowa, Minnesota, Nebraska, North Dakota and South Dakota. The company says the compressed CO2 will be permanently and safely stored in saline reservoirs deep underground in North Dakota.

The federal tax credits that will be part of the financing for this project do not allow for the reuse of the carbon dioxide — it must be permanently sequestered.

"The essence of the project is to really support the ethanol industry from both an environmental standpoint and a financial standpoint, and thereby enhance the long-term outlook for the agriculture economy in the five states we operate in," Caruso said.

The Kandiyohi County portion of the pipeline is part of the central branch in Minnesota. It is the longest branch of the three in the state being proposed by Summit, at about 175 miles, and would connect four ethanol plants.

The other two branches are the southern branch — from Fairmont, Minnesota, to Superior, Iowa — and the northern branch — from Fergus Falls, Minnesota, to the North Dakota border. So far, Summit has applied for a permit only for the northern branch.

The hope is to apply for the southern branch permit this quarter and for the central branch permit sometime this year. Caruso said it could take between 12 to 18 months for the permit to be approved or denied.

The pipeline's route through Kandiyohi County is still in flux. Summit Carbon cannot use eminent domain in Minnesota, so it's only with landowner approval that the pipeline can go across private property. This means the pipeline might have to take a more serpentine route through the counties, adding miles to the route.

There have been some landowners in Kandiyohi County who have signed on to the project, Caruso said.


"We have to essentially lock it down before we file with the Public Utilities Commission," with the route and then permitting, Caruso said.

More on Summit Carbon Solutions:
The first Minnesota Public Utilities Commission meetings on the Summit Carbon Solutions carbon capture pipeline was May 2 in Breckenridge and May 3 in Fergus Falls.
The Minnesota Public Utilities Commission met on Jan. 5, 2023, to consider the application for Summit Carbon Solutions.
Summit Carbon Solutions hopes to begin construction next September
Iowa-based Summit Carbon Solutions says its $4.5 billion pipeline project will help ethanol plants, including the Green Plains Ethanol plant at Fergus Falls, Minnesota, lower their carbon scores. The project aims to capture greenhouse gas emissions and pipe the CO2 to western North Dakota for underground storage.
Landowners and community menmbers in Redwood and Cottonwood counties voiced concerns about proposed Summit Carbon Solutions proposed project at meeting in Lamberton, according to the Clean Up our River Environment organization.
Summit Carbon Solutions discussed its proposed carbon dioxide pipeline project with the Kandiyohi County Board on Tuesday. Approximately 27 miles of the pipeline would go through Kandiyohi County, connecting the Bushmills Ethanol plant near Atwater with the company’s larger pipeline network. There were some concerns raised by the board about the possible environmental and public safety impacts the project could have.
The decision means carbon pipeline companies must file for a siting permit with the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission. Without statewide authority, permitting would have been left up to individual counties along the pipeline route.
The Montevideo-based nonprofit Clean Up the River Environment told the Yellow Medicine County Board of Commissioners its concerns about risks associated with what would be a first-of-its-kind project by Summit Carbon Solutions. The $4.5 billion project would build a five-state, 2,000-mile pipeline network — with about 200 miles in Minnesota — to transport carbon dioxide from ethanol plants for sequestration in North Dakota.
Summit Carbon Solutions has hosted six open house meetings in Minnesota for landowners along the proposed route of a pipeline to carry carbon dioxide. The number one message from those meetings has been concern about drain tiles, company officials told the Yellow Medicine County Board of Commissioners.
Bushmills Ethanol is the 32nd ethanol plant to officially join Summit Carbon Solutions’ transformative carbon capture and storage project.

The sole purpose of the pipeline is to help reduce the carbon footprint of the ethanol industry. California, Oregon and Washington already have low carbon fuel standards, and Minnesota is considered one of the states likely to put similar rules in place, along with Canada. Summit Carbon hopes to work with that trend.

"There is a big trend nationally and internationally to decarbonize industry, whether it is ag, power generation or refinery," Caruso said. "This is just one strategy to help with that."

Caruso said safety is a top priority for Summit Carbon. There are more than 5,000 miles of CO2 pipelines across the country, and while there have been major incidents, these pipelines overall have been relatively safe, Caruso said.

Not all the Kandiyohi County Commissioners are supportive of the project.

Commissioner Steve Gardner said he has real concerns about the safety of the pipeline and what it could do the county's environment if there is a breach. He also doesn't think this project will do much to help the environment either, as it will only take the equivalent of 3.9 million vehicles off the road when there are approximately 285 million driving in the United States.

"I would suggest that this might not necessarily be the environmental savior that it is being reported to be. It is an economic opportunity for certain companies to profit in this space," Gardner said. "My concerns revolve around certainly safety and sustainability. I am not on board, I am not a believer."

However, others on the board weren't so against the project's proposed benefits.


"We need to try and do something about it from an environmental point of view. There aren't a lot of options we have; I am very serious on looking at this option. I think it has some good possibilities." said Commissioner Corky Berg, though he too believed safety would be the main concern. "Maybe it is a big Band-Aid, but it is a Band-Aaid versus not doing anything."

Shelby Lindrud is a reporter with the West Central Tribune of Willmar. Her focus areas are arts and entertainment, agriculture, features writing and the Kandiyohi County Board.

She can be reached via email or direct 320-214-4373.

What To Read Next
Get Local