Cal Thomas: Meloni baloney about Italy's new leader

From the commentary: You can understand why secular progressives hate Italy's new leader Giorgia Meloni and fear her message. Perhaps she will soon visit the U.S. and put some backbone into the Republican Party.

FILE PHOTO: Leader of Brothers of Italy Giorgia Meloni speaks at the party's election night headquarters, in Rome, Italy September 26, 2022.
FILE PHOTO: Leader of Brothers of Italy Giorgia Meloni speaks at the party's election night headquarters, in Rome, Italy September 26, 2022.
REUTERS / Guglielmo Mangiapane
We are part of The Trust Project.

Italy has elected its first female prime minister. Normally that would be cause for celebration by those who promote diversity, but press reaction in Europe and the United States is treating Giorgia Meloni as the second coming of Italian dictator and Adolf Hitler ally, Benito Mussolini.

Cal Thomas commentary
Cal Thomas Commentary
Tribune graphic
Summary: I once heard the late evangelist Rev. Billy Graham say America was not at a crossroads, but had traveled down the wrong road and needed to come back to the crossroads and take the right road. What if we can no longer agree on the right road and where the wrong road is leading us?
Summary: Donald Trump would do well to withdraw from the field and allow younger and less controversial candidates to replace him. His record of policy successes while president are undeniable (except for those in denial), but his narcissistic personality contributed to his loss. It is also contributing to the work of the January 6 committee. If that committee wishes to "bring us together," it will forgo recommendations of criminal prosecution and let voters decide, as they should and ultimately will, the future of Donald Trump.
Summary: When rhetoric gets heated, perhaps the best way to be heard is to speak in a tone Scripture attributes to God — "a still, small voice." As noted by the writer of Proverbs: "A gentle answer turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger. (Proverbs 15:1)
Summary: Many viewers might want to know why Congress can't seem to fix any of the country's real problems. That perennial question is why increasing numbers of Americans have grown sour about Washington. They see members of Congress more interested in re-election, in their careers and in perks than in the people they are supposed to represent.

The leftist press labels those whose policies they oppose as "right wing," "extremist" and in Meloni's case, a woman with "fascist" associations and political roots. A Washington Post editorial calls her a "firebrand ethno-nationalist" whose party "arose from the ashes of post-World War II Italian fascism." Having already smeared her, the Post then contradicts itself, writing: "In fact, it would be a stretch to regard Ms. Meloni ... as a fascist."

Meloni's political positions are opposed to the secular progressive agenda. She is passionately pro-life, opposes the LGBTQ political agenda, and wants to restrict immigration. Market Realist News says: "Much like many far-right politicians in the U.S., Meloni has utilized her Christian views to serve as a backbone of her politics." And secular progressives don't do the same?

Meloni's Brothers of Italy party, which she co-founded in 2012, and which repeatedly described as "far right," so you get their drift, evolved from a neo-fascist movement, a movement begun decades ago. Meloni says her views are not those of that older organization. For the left, one can evolve in their direction, but never the opposite.

It is always best to hear someone speak for themselves without the filtration of a hostile media.


Three years ago, Meloni spoke before The World Congress of Families in Verona. She began with self-deprecating humor: "I've just arrived ... I was doing the ironing. Then I found 10 minutes to come and talk politics with you."

Meloni said of the stereotypes associated with the family organization: "They said all sorts of things about this congress. They said we want to go back to the past. That we're losers. That we're embarrassing. That we're un-enlightened. They said it's scandalous for people to defend the natural family founded on marriage, to want to increase the birth rate, to want to place the correct value on human life, to support freedom in education and to say no to gender ideology."

The same has been said by critics of conservatives and their organizations in the U.S., but her platform is in tune with many Americans.

Like Donald Trump and Florida Governor Ron DeSantis, she is not shy about firing back at her critics, some of whom were protesting outside the venue: "I say the losers are those who have nothing better to do than come here and insult us."

She has proposed free nursery schools for mothers who work outside the home. She describes Europe's low birth rate (much of it thanks to liberal abortion policies) as "the biggest problem facing Europe." Not energy? Not Russia's war against Ukraine? Nope. "If we do not address this," she says, "everything else is pointless."

More Commentary:
From the commentary:
From the commentary: Perhaps the ultimate point is that Pompeo’s attack on Weingarten and teachers must do just that. Pompeo’s demagogic words must bring together all the sane patriots who still call themselves Republicans. They must unite to condemn his message — and tell Americans we must work with our teachers to help them build the infrastructure that will be America’s ultimate bridge to tomorrow.
From the commentary: Ocasio-Cortez has a long record of pushing primary challenges to Democrats deemed insufficiently radical. These attempts are almost always unsuccessful though draining to the incumbent.

Meloni also has a searing response to critics who claim she wants to return Italy to the Middle Ages: "The Middle Ages was also the time of the cathedrals and the abbeys, the founding of the comuni (small Italian administrative units), the universities, the parliament, the epoch of Dante, Petrarch, Boccaccio, Saint Francis, Saint Benedict. People who don't know where Matera is, let's not expect them to read history books."

How about this zinger: "I believe in a society where every choice has consequences and you accept responsibility for them. I reject a society where every desire becomes a right." That once was considered normal and admirable in America and in Europe.

You can understand why secular progressives hate her and fear her message. Perhaps she will soon visit the U.S. and put some backbone into the Republican Party.


This Cal Thomas commentary is his opinion. He can be reached at

Commentary logo
Commentary logo
Tribune graphic

Related Topics: COMMENTARY
What to read next
Ann Bailey explains why she's thankful for agriculture in professional and personal life.
From the commentary: This fetish with identity started as a tic of the left, which tends to believe that voters want candidates who represent certain groups, as opposed to certain ideas. What it should have learned by now is that Republicans are perfectly capable of running their own candidates of color, witness their support in the Georgia senate race of the unintelligible Herschel Walker, a Black football player.
From the commentary: Still, as Biden quietly marked his 80th birthday on Nov. 13, the basic Democratic dilemma remained: Will it be best for the party — and the country — to renominate the nation’s oldest president, even if the alternative is chaos?
"After a couple of years of celebrating apart because of the pandemic, and also for having just lived through another rancorous national election, we all could use the joy and hope and anticipation that is promised us in Christmas, in the birth of a mighty little king born in a manger."