Carl P. Leubsdorf: Rocky road ahead for McCarthy

From the commentary: Those kinds of cross-party relationships don’t exist in today’s hyper-partisan world, so McCarthy will be pretty much flying solo.

House Minority Leader Rep. Kevin McCarthy (R-CA) delivers remarks to supporters during a watch party at the Westin Hotel on Nov. 9, 2022, in Washington, DC.
House Minority Leader Rep. Kevin McCarthy (R-CA) delivers remarks to supporters during a watch party at the Westin Hotel on Nov. 9, 2022, in Washington, DC. Republicans will take control of the House of Representatives away from Democrats.
(Sarah Silbiger/Getty Images/TNS)
We are part of The Trust Project.

For the past two years, Democratic Speaker Nancy Pelosi has conducted a political science class in how to manage the House of Representatives with a bare four-seat majority.

More Commentary:
From the commentary:
From the commentary: Perhaps the ultimate point is that Pompeo’s attack on Weingarten and teachers must do just that. Pompeo’s demagogic words must bring together all the sane patriots who still call themselves Republicans. They must unite to condemn his message — and tell Americans we must work with our teachers to help them build the infrastructure that will be America’s ultimate bridge to tomorrow.
From the commentary: Ocasio-Cortez has a long record of pushing primary challenges to Democrats deemed insufficiently radical. These attempts are almost always unsuccessful though draining to the incumbent.

The result, backed by a Democratic White House and Senate, has been a spate of significant bipartisan legislation — a long-sought infrastructure bill and measures spurring domestic chips production, expanding veterans’ health programs and gun safety rules — plus Democratic priorities like curbing drug prices and combatting climate change.

Now, Republican Kevin McCarthy is facing a similar challenge, assuming he can surmount the internal resistance that has left his ascent somewhat in doubt.

But his speakership is likely to be very different from Pelosi’s, focusing much more on oversight and investigations than on legislation. That’s because he’ll be a Republican island in a Democratic sea, forced to confront a Democratic Senate and a Democratic president while barely able to control his fractious Republican House.

By all accounts, McCarthy, like Pelosi, is a prodigious fund-raiser but lacks the legislative skills she developed in 20 years as the Democrats’ top leader.


As a result, the GOP-controlled House may encounter difficulty passing all but the most routine legislation, especially the appropriations bills that are needed to fund the government. And it may only be able to muster a majority to raise the legal ceiling on the national debt — another necessity — by attaching conditions unacceptable to the Senate and the president or working with the Democrats, something McCarthy has never been able to do.

Besides, not only do GOP leaders face pressures from the three dozen members of the conservative Freedom Caucus that sank two previous Republican speakers, but the election produced a handful of more moderate GOP members from predominantly Democratic states. Their priorities are likely to be different from those of the Freedom Caucus.

So it is hardly surprising that, even before Republicans clinched their House majority, the likely head of their Oversight Committee was publicly discussing his plans to pursue an investigation of President Joe Biden’s son, Hunter — and his father.

Rep. James Comer, R-Ky., told CBS News last week he believes Hunter Biden’s overseas business dealings may have "compromised this White House."

“Therefore, it's a national security concern," Comer said “And we take that very seriously, and we're going to press forward with a credible, formal investigation of the president of the United States."

The Bidens are not likely to be the only high-level GOP target. Earlier this week, a group of House and Senate Republicans met to discuss possible probes that reportedly included one on the COVID-19 pandemic likely to focus on Dr. Anthony Fauci.

They included Comer; Ohio Rep. Jim Jordan, likely to chair the Judiciary Committee; and four investigation-minded GOP senators, Chuck Grassley of Iowa, Rand Paul of Kentucky, Roger Marshall of Kansas and Ron Johnson of Wisconsin. Paul, who would have been a subcommittee chairman in a Republican Senate, has frequently clashed with Fauci, while both Grassley and Johnson have pressed efforts to probe Hunter Biden.

Among other non-legislative items on the House GOP agenda: retaliatory moves against the outgoing Democratic majority, including an effort to remove several prominent Democrats from their committees. Targets include Intelligence Committee Chair Adam Schiff and controversial liberal Minnesota Rep. Ilhan Omar.


It would be a response to the Democrats’ ouster of right-wing firebrands Reps. Marjorie Taylor Greene of Georgia and Paul Gosar of Arizona from their committees for threatening Democratic lawmakers. The GOP plans to reinstate both, disband the Jan. 6 investigating committee and scrap measures the Democrats instituted to cope with the pandemic, like proxy voting and metal detectors.

In the next few weeks, McCarthy will have to mollify enough GOP holdouts to ensure he gets 218 votes when the House meets Jan. 3 and elects its speaker. Pelosi was able to do that when confronted with similar resistance after the Democrats took over the House in the 2018 election.

But that won’t be the end of it. Having such a minuscule GOP margin will repeatedly enable recalcitrant members to pressure McCarthy, like rival moderate and progressive Democratic factions did to Pelosi the past two years.

That’s one reason for Republicans to choose the easier path of confrontation. Another might be pressure from former President Donald Trump, who has substantial influence with McCarthy and had a better record electing GOP House members than governors and senators.

Trump, who formally announced Tuesday night he is seeking the 2024 GOP nomination, is already reportedly pushing for a confrontational approach. According to a pre-election Rolling Stone article, Trump has been calling his House allies, asking about their plans to impeach Biden.

But the Republicans will have to face the fact that, although they flipped House control, the results were far more red ripple than red wave. Their margin will rival the outgoing Democrats in having the smallest House majority in 70 years.

More Opinion:
From the commentary: This fetish with identity started as a tic of the left, which tends to believe that voters want candidates who represent certain groups, as opposed to certain ideas. What it should have learned by now is that Republicans are perfectly capable of running their own candidates of color, witness their support in the Georgia senate race of the unintelligible Herschel Walker, a Black football player.
From the commentary: Still, as Biden quietly marked his 80th birthday on Nov. 13, the basic Democratic dilemma remained: Will it be best for the party — and the country — to renominate the nation’s oldest president, even if the alternative is chaos?
From the commentary: We have become hyphenated Americans with too many clinging to their native land in language and culture. No nation can be sustained in its character without controlling who is allowed to enter. Other nations have far more restrictive immigration laws and paths to citizenship than ours.
From the commentary: The question becomes: How much further can we keep expanding the number of domestic birds that are grown and slaughtered? How much longer can this vicious cycle continue before it explodes?
From the commentary: Americans want better results. They want a government that’s efficient and effective and improves their lives. They expect and deserve elected leaders who will fix the damn roads.
From the commentary: It's a safe assumption that fear of crime is what flipped several suburban New York congressional districts to Republicans. The fears may not match the reality, but elected officials should not add fuel to them with careless talk. Kathy Hochul was lucky this time.
From the commentary: From all the reporting I've done about the Latino vote over the past three decades, along with the experience I've had for nearly 40 years as a Latino voter, there are a handful of factors that determine whether Latinos — who tend to register Democratic by 2 to 1— are at least open to voting for a Republican.
From the commentary: In his new book "So Help Me God," Pence quotes Trump as pressuring him to overturn the results of the 2020 election by rejecting electoral votes from the states. When he refuses, Pence says Trump told him "you're too honest." It was cynicism at its worst and what so many people hate about Washington and politics.
From the commentary: Cartoonist Dick Wright draws on Donald Trump's attacks on other Republicans.
From the commentary: DeSantis, Kemp, Abbot and other governors like them make the best presidential candidates for Republicans. ... They’re the ones who know how to fix things and get things done.

The margin was almost identical when the Democrats regained the House in 1954 in the first midterm election of President Dwight D. Eisenhower’s administration, after Republican had held a similarly narrow majority the prior two years.

But the climate was far different, and their leader, Speaker Sam Rayburn, was a Texan who worked closely with fellow Texas natives Lyndon Johnson, the Senate Democratic leader, and Eisenhower.


Those kinds of cross-party relationships don’t exist in today’s hyper-partisan world, so McCarthy will be pretty much flying solo.

Carl P. Leubsdorf is the former Washington bureau chief of the Dallas Morning News. Readers may write to him via email at This commentary is the columnist's opinion. Send feedback to:

©2022 The Dallas Morning News. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.


This story was written by one of our partner news agencies. Forum Communications Company uses content from agencies such as Reuters, Kaiser Health News, Tribune News Service and others to provide a wider range of news to our readers. Learn more about the news services FCC uses here.

Related Topics: COMMENTARY
What to read next
Ann Bailey explains why she's thankful for agriculture in professional and personal life.
"After a couple of years of celebrating apart because of the pandemic, and also for having just lived through another rancorous national election, we all could use the joy and hope and anticipation that is promised us in Christmas, in the birth of a mighty little king born in a manger."
Katie Pinke looks at the positive impact of 4-H on youth.
"Six Nations speak of a principle called the seventh-generation teaching, where leaders are instructed to 'consider the impact of their decisions on the seventh generation from now.' That’s a profound teaching, and a stark contrast to America’s current political promises, four-year terms, special interest lobbying and decisions based on quarterly profits. How about if we thought long term?"