Froma Harrop: Climate bill should please anyone who can be pleased

From the commentary: The measure still has some legislative hurdles to jump over before it becomes a reality. But for the evenly divided Senate controlled by Democrats, Manchin could have been the biggest hurdle.

Froma Harrop Commentary
We are part of The Trust Project.

What? Good news in the fight to save the planet from rising temperatures?

Froma Harrop Commentary
Tribune graphic
More Froma Harrop
Summary: Demand for gasoline keeps rising. But so apparently is demand for space on the roads. Moan about high gas prices, if you must. The traffic doesn't seem to have noticed.
Summary: If the activist left succeeded in portraying itself as the heart and soul of the Democratic Party, the fault lies in much of the political media. Rather than sending Democrats a message, California has sent the media a message on where Democrats really stand on crime. ... Guess what? They don't like it.
Summary: Had Cuellar lost to Cisneros in the Texas primary, the results would not have been a new lefty in Congress but another Democratic seat lost to a Republican. Smart progressives know that real power comes from supporting candidates, who, even if not their ideal, can get elected.

Yes. It comes in the form of a bill than pleases both Sen. Joe Manchin and the Natural Resources Defense Council. It gives the senator from West Virginia some political chips — basically, money for West Virginians and a slightly looser leash on fossil fuels. However, the emissions cuts envisioned in the bill could be 10 times bigger than the carbon released by helping said emitters, according to the NRDC, an environmental powerhouse.

The bottom line is that by 2030, the United States could slash its greenhouse emissions some 40% below 2005 levels.

Americans, don't let the good news bore you. And ignore fringe environmental groups who are sniping at the bill over its trade-offs. I won't even name them here. If the NRDC says this bill is a super deal for confronting climate change, it's a super deal.


This summer has produced enough apocalyptic weather to concentrate the mind on the ugly realities of a warming planet. Most recent was the catastrophic flooding in eastern Kentucky. The extraordinary nine inches of rainfall in 12 hours was "simply in its own Universe," tweeted Jeff Berardelli, a prominent Florida meteorologist. "With climate change, what was almost impossible then is now not only possible, it's probable."

The deluge was a 1-in-1,000-year catastrophe, the kind of rare event that's increasingly not rare. When it comes to weather, a millennium is not what it sued to be.

The dwindling water supplies in the Southwest represent the flip side of climate change. Some places drown while others bake.

Britain's heat wave produced a record-breaking high of 104.5 degrees Fahrenheit. The heat fueled so many fires in London that the city's firefighters were the busiest they've been since the Nazi blitz attacks during World War II.


Climate scientists concluded that such heat would have been "extremely unlikely" without global warming.

And so what's in this bill might actually do something? For starters, it would spend hundreds of billions on wind turbines, solar panels, electric vehicles and other technologies that would slash carbon emissions.

Manchin was made rich by coal and has long been a friend of fossil fuels. He is running for reelection in a Trump-loving state that does not always recognize how much of its coal industry is gone. And so the question must be asked: What's in it for Manchin?

There are a scattering of goodies for fossil fuel producers. For one, the federal government would have to open more public lands to drilling, though the extractors would have to pay higher royalties. It would streamline energy infrastructure projects, a boon for both clean energy and the other kind.

It would offer tax credits for carbon capture and storage technologies. Some purists complain that this enables plants to continue running on fossil fuels because the technology would reduce their carbon emissions. On the other hand, reducing carbon emissions is a good thing. Extending the life of some facilities seems a political price worth paying for a much steeper drop in emissions elsewhere.


Who could object to the bill's incentives for building wind and solar farms in areas where coal mines or plants have closed? The United Mine Workers of America really like the idea -- in addition to the part that preserves the federal trust fund for workers with black lung disease.

The measure still has some legislative hurdles to jump over before it becomes a reality. But for the evenly divided Senate controlled by Democrats, Manchin could have been the biggest hurdle.

For once, let's set aside political considerations. Climate change is an existential threat. Left unchallenged, the abyss would swallow us all.

Froma Harrop can be reached at or on Twitter @FromaHarrop .

More Commetary:
Museum hours and special events in the next month
The weekly Around Our Region calendar of events is published Wednesdays. Submissions may be emailed to with “Around our Region” in the subject line at least a week in advance.
Bruins are part of long-term research by wildlife biologists.
"Canadian Pacific Railway wants to merge with the Kansas City Southern Railway, and that means more oil-filled trains and dangerous freight ... What if trains moved people and not dirty oil? The U.S. has the least developed passenger train system of any first world country. That’s a shame."
The Minnesota Gun Owners Caucus questions whether the fair’s ban on firearms violates Minnesota state statutes and the U.S. Constitution.
From the commentary: The economy matters most of all. But the return to view of some traditional issues — abortion rights and taxing the wealthy — have helped Democrats regain their mojo. They should do their best to stick with that rather than open new fights or reopen old ones.
The Kandiyohi County Historical Society is celebrating its 125th anniversary at the Pioneer Cabin on the Kandiyohi County Fairgrounds.
Support groups, clinics and health classes are published weekly on Wednesdays. Email submissions to by 10 a.m. at least a week in advance.
Food columnist Sarah Nasello says this recipe for this Savory Tomato Cheddar Galette is her gift to you — layers of pure summer deliciousness (tomatoes, garlic and cheese) encased in a scrumptious, rich and buttery pie crust laced with fresh herbs and flavor.
Wes and Linda Julson haven't yet given up on the hope of finding their daughter, Michelle "Shelly" Julson, who went missing from Bismarck on Aug. 2, 1994, they tell the Dakota Spotlight podcast, which is reinvestigating the cold case aided by the police file on Shelly's disappearance.

Related Topics: COMMENTARY
What to read next
From the commentary: At the moment, are any Republicans backing the Federal Bureau of Investigation? The Trumpistas — who talk a good game about supporting cops — don't seem too keen on federal law enforcement now that the FBI has raided Trump's private residence at Mar-a-Lago.
Some people claim the devil himself visited the tiny town of Villisca, Iowa, that summer night in 1912, when 8 people were killed by an ax murderer. Others say he already lived among them. After more than a century of idle gossip and speculation, some amateur sleuths might have just figured it out.
From the commentary: As George Santayana famously said, "Those who do not learn history are doomed to repeat it." Times change, but human nature never changes. David McCullough has shown why the lessons of history remain important, especially for those determined not to repeat history's mistakes and to learn from its successes.
The peach crops from the south have been slow because of a variety of weather problems, Jenny Schlecht learned. It was a good reminder that farming isn't easy whether you've got wheat fields or orchards.