We see that you have javascript disabled. Please enable javascript and refresh the page to continue reading local news. If you feel you have received this message in error, please contact the customer support team at 1-833-248-7801.



Rekha Basu: Don't be swayed by fear-mongering ads from unclear interests

From the commentary: So do the research and vet these ads before believing them. And to poor Mrs. Smith, please get a real doctor, and take heart that your drug prices should actually go down. Unless, of course, you're diabetic.

A pedestrian walks past the Leading Insurance Agency, which offers plans under the Affordable Care Act (also known as Obamacare) on Jan. 28, 2021 in Miami, Florida.
A pedestrian walks past the Leading Insurance Agency, which offers plans under the Affordable Care Act (also known as Obamacare) on Jan. 28, 2021 in Miami, Florida.
Joe Raedle/Getty Images/TNS
We are part of The Trust Project.

A grim-faced doctor walks into an examining room where an anxious white-haired woman sits on the table, awaiting news. “Mrs. Smith, I have your test results here,” the doctor announces as the woman smiles up at him. “The news isn’t good."

More Commentary:
From the commentary: ... The question of whether state courts should enforce state constitutional protections of voting rights should be easy to answer with a resounding yes. That it is an open question is clearly what troubled the conference of chief justices, and rightly so.
From the commentary: Even in a season marked by unpredictability, some things never change. Politics is still a street fight. And it never hurts to get in the first punch.
From the commentary: You can understand why secular progressives hate Italy's new leader Giorgia Meloni and fear her message. Perhaps she will soon visit the U.S. and put some backbone into the Republican Party.

Perhaps you've seen this TV ad, which was airing in Des Moines and had me alternately laughing out loud and wanting to throw something at the screen — neither the most useful or mature response.

The smile fades. The camera pans down to her clutched, wrinkled hands as he continues, “Unfortunately, Congress is considering a bill that would strip nearly $300 billion in Medicare to pay for Obamacare, and research on this treatment may be stopped.”

Close-up on the woman's face — bewildered, scared — as the doctor tells her to get her affairs in order: "I wish I had better treatment options for you, but I really think it’s time you start talking to your family. I’m sorry." Then he abruptly walks out, leaving her to gaze heavenward.

Have they no shame? The ad was placed by an outfit called “Center for Innovation and Free Enterprise, a project of Americans for A Balanced Budget, Inc.,” about which little is known. A message on the screen instructs viewers to "Call Iowa's Democratic Congresswoman Cindy Axne and tell her to oppose the federal Budget Reconciliation bill" — the Inflation Reduction Act that passed the Senate last week.


Besides the fact a real doctor saying such things should be fired for spreading bogus fears in a vulnerable patient in the defense of drug manufacturers' obscene profits, the law would actually benefit patients. A similar ad in another market "misleadingly paints what is more accurately characterized as nearly $300 billion in savings for consumers and taxpayers," says Politifact, the fact-checking arm of the Poynter Institute journalism think tank. That ad is attributed to the American Prosperity Alliance.

The New York Times explains what the bill would do: “For the first time, Medicare would be allowed to negotiate with drugmakers on the price of prescription medicines, a proposal projected to save the federal government billions of dollars. That would apply to 10 drugs initially, beginning in 2026, and then expand to include more drugs in the following years.”

As for the Obamacare part, the Times notes that its subsidies were expanded last year under the Democratic-passed $1.9 trillion pandemic aid package. It would either make some plans free for lower-income people or extend "some support to higher-income people who previously did not receive any aid," the Times says. Those subsidies are set to expire at the end of the year, but the law would continue them for three more years.

The Times says this would represent the largest expansion of federal health policy since passage of the Affordable Care Act, capping out-of-pocket costs for seniors at $2,000 a year, and ensuring their vaccines were free.

More Opinion:
From the commentary: A more targeted CDC messaging campaign would prioritize the 35% of people over 65 who haven’t been boosted at all; they’d benefit the most from the retooled booster. Next on the priority list would be the over-65s who haven’t been boosted or been infected during the last six months. Even if they already had one booster, there’s now evidence that getting a second booster reduces the risk of death, so a second shot is worth it.
From the commentary: Maybe our current slide into fascism won’t continue; we don’t know yet, and the answer will be up to us. But we do have reason to believe that “America First,” means essentially the same thing to My Pillow’s Mike Lindell that it did to Charles Lindbergh.
From the commentary: President Biden is no Bill Clinton. The Democratic Party has been taken over by the hard left and they are not about to compromise on anything, from social issues to "climate change." ... Only if Republicans win the Congress and the White House does the GOP "Commitment to America" have a chance to fully succeed.
From the commentary: Sadly, even assuming a happy ending for a revised Electoral Count Act, that's not the takeaway from this legislative saga. Instead, what stands out is that Congress couldn't get unanimity in either house on its attempts to rewrite a badly drafted 19th century law that was at the center of a bloody attack on the lawmakers' own corridors and, potentially, their lives.
Election administrators and judges are part of the community. We are your neighbors and co-workers, people you see at church on Sunday or in line at the grocery store. I believe I speak for all election officials when I say we are honest citizens who want to serve our community to the best of our ability.
From the commentary: Viewing t.. the Court as just another political institution staffed by the usual hacks, deprives the Court of the grandeur and dignity that an institution without an army to enforce its decisions needs to be respected. The rule of law holds force ... because of the power of our belief, both in the law and in the people enforcing it.
From the commentary: The one thing we can do is build relationships at the local level. The notion of building relationships across differences can feel quixotic. But part of the beauty of being human is that we have the capacity for empathy and kindness, and these feelings can grow even in the most painful circumstances.
From the commentary: So, the ideological, political and legal war rages on. Welcome back, justices.
From the commentary: Given the size of the egos involved, there was never much of a chance that Gov. Ron DeSantis and former president Donald Trump would wind up sharing a ticket. But now, they might end up sharing a cell.
From the commentary: Progressives tend to blame systems, rather than individual choices, for disparities in everything from income to health. But sometimes, those choices matter more than any system.

The Washington Post provides this context: When Medicare Part D, which pays for prescription drugs, was first passed under President George W. Bush, the federal government was prevented from negotiating drug prices. That was left to manufacturers, private health plans, and pharmacies, all of which had their own interests. But having the federal Health and Human Services Department directly negotiate prices should bring down the cost of drugs, especially newer, high-priced medications.

What the ad is really saying is that if drug manufacturers were compelled to give up any profits, they might respond by cutting spending on researching new drugs. And if that were to happen, it's those companies consumers should be instructed to call — to stop feeding off the pain of ordinary Americans who can't afford obscenely inflated drug prices.

So, why are these ads being placed? "The American Prosperity Alliance has almost no online profile," says Politifact. Online, the Alliance says its public policy project prioritizes limited government and free markets: "We support an economy in which the prices for goods and services are determined by the open market and consumers, in which the laws and forces of supply and demand are free from any intervention by a government, price-setting monopoly, or other authority."

In plain English, it believes that having the government intervene on behalf of consumers threatens to restrain unchecked profits to industry.


In other words, that's good.

What isn't good, and what campaign ads for the upcoming elections should be seizing upon, is that Senate Republicans, including Iowa's Chuck Grassley and Joni Ernst, sold out people with diabetes during debate on that same budget reconciliation bill. They blocked a provision to cap out-of-pocket pay for insulin at $35 a month under private insurance.

With midterm elections three months away, we'll be seeing lots of political ads making grandiose claims for or against candidates or issues. And under the Supreme Court's ill-advised Citizens United ruling, corporations can and will spend limitless amounts to influence public opinion. That can — and in my view has in recent years — gotten ordinary, working people to vote against their own economic interests, with disastrous consequences.

So do the research and vet these ads before believing them. And to poor Mrs. Smith, please get a real doctor, and take heart that your drug prices should actually go down. Unless, of course, you're diabetic.

Rekha Basu is a columnist for the Des Moines Register. Readers may send her email at rbasu@dmreg.com.

©2022 Des Moines Register. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.


This story was written by one of our partner news agencies. Forum Communications Company uses content from agencies such as Reuters, Kaiser Health News, Tribune News Service and others to provide a wider range of news to our readers. Learn more about the news services FCC uses here.

Related Topics: COMMENTARY
What to read next
"As an agricultural reporter, my job is to report the news."
The Scandia Lutheran Church in Averill, Minnesota, held its last worship service on July 17. It sold off everything that was accumulated in 123 years of service, from the altar to the communion service set to even the metal coat racks that hung in the vestibule.
"Growing up in upper Midwest agriculture taught me the certainty of two things: consistently inconsistent weather and regular disputes between the Farm Bureau and Farmers Union, the area's two largest farm organizations."
Sept. 4 comes and goes with a blur for many. For me there are three dates: Sept. 4, 1863; Sept. 4, 2016, and Sept. 4, 2022. This is really about the Indian Wars, which continue. I think it’s time to end the Indian Wars. It’s also time to understand that forensic facts, are not “critical race theory,” they are what happened. As school begins, let us ensure that history is taught, and that we make good choices today.