ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Phil Drietz letter: Here are more CO2 facts as I see them

The letter writer responds to response to his previous letter.

We are part of The Trust Project.

The Aug. 20, 2022 letter response to my recent letter to the West Central Tribune states that though CO2 is a small percentage of the atmosphere.

readeropinion12-man.jpg
The letter writer calls for support of The National Climate Adaptation and Resilience Strategy Act.
The letter writer criticizes the idea of changing the name of Sibley State Park.
The letter writers call for collective effort to address gun violence.

Actually, only 3.6% of the atmosphere is CO2, and only 3.2% of that, is man-made. So only about 0.117% of CO2 greenhouse effect is man-made. It’s too small to affect the global heat budget.

Water vapor, a greenhouse gas, traps about 1,300 times more heat than man’s CO2. That’s based on a 1% global atmospheric water vapor content. However, it can at times go up to 4% in places. Even a somewhat small up or down change in the massive quantity of water vapor may release or absorb far more heat, and therefore have more effect on temperature, than would a doubling of our current tiny CO2 level. Oceans have a huge effect on water vapor level depending on the amount of cloud cover blocking the sun’s energy.

Also, note that a rise in atmospheric CO2 level seems to follow a rise in temperature of the ocean surface water, lagging behind by about 10-11 months (Humlum et. al. (2013). Rising CO2 levels are due to the earth's temperature rise; not the other way around.

Author cites a NASA list of 200 academies that say CO2 is the ‘culprit’. Truth isn’t determined by majority vote. We need only look at the number of scientists who say ‘molecules to man’ macro-evolution is real, when in fact it cannot be defended.

ADVERTISEMENT

My Aug. 13, 2022 letter referenced satellite data telling us that the reduction in sulfate and nitrate particle pollution in the atmosphere is causing global warming by reducing the amount of sun energy reflecting back into space. It’s a trade-off; more pollution or more heat waves.

You’re never going to have ‘squeaky clean’ air. Annual land fires burn an area equivalent to the western U.S., pumping out about 2.2 billion tons of carbon, along with carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxide, etc. Volcanoes emit up to 25 million tons of sulfur dioxide.

How ironic that environmentalism is contributing to global warming.

Phil Drietz
Delhi, Minnesota

More opinion content:
From the commentary: It is time for our new congressional leaders to make history by bringing a new era of unity to our tired old partisan gun politics. Be it resolved: The “Party of Law-and-Order”
From the editorial: If a major presidential candidate calling for eliminating the Constitution isn’t enough to merit a preemptive, party-wide rejection of his candidacy, what is?
From the commentary: The federal government is taking in a record amount of revenue, but spending more than it receives and Democrats want to spend even more. Why is Congress deaf to the warnings of
From the editorial: "The sad reality is that busy lives roll on. ... New moments of significance occur. Those who lived through and were affected by the horribleness of significant events start
From the commentary: That is the silver lining, if there is one, of today’s bitter, culturally charged partisan warfare: It has made civic engagement more meaningful for millions of citizens,
From the commentary: r decades, the Supreme Court has been clear that stopping discrimination is more important than protecting the freedom to discriminate. The court should reaffirm this principle
From the editorial: School officials need to recognize that this may be their only chance to reverse the harms imposed by the pandemic. First, districts should gather data to determine the scale of
An editorial cartoon by Dave Granlund.
From the commentary: This much is clear. Strengthening Harris' numbers is in the administration's best political interest. The more comfortable people are with Vice President Kamala Harris, the more

What to read next
The letter writer celebrates the decade-long government effort to complete the Willmar Wye.